A first date can be both exciting and nerve-wracking. It’s your chance to make a genuine connection, but it’s also easy to fall into habits that sabotage your chances of a second meeting. Knowing what not to do on a first date can save you from awkward moments, misunderstandings, and missed opportunities. Here’s a guide to the most common first date mistakes—and what to do instead.
Or you prefer rather to call? +41 22 900 11 28
Before you focus on making the perfect impression, it’s worth knowing the common pitfalls that can derail a promising connection. These are the most frequent first date mistakes to avoid if you want the evening to flow naturally and leave both of you wanting more.
One of the quickest ways to ruin a first date is by treating it like a high-stakes audition for a long-term relationship. While wanting to make a good impression is normal, overthinking every word and gesture can create tension rather than chemistry. Excessive pressure—on yourself or your date—turns a relaxed evening into a performance, which can leave both of you feeling drained rather than excited for a second date.
Good conversation is a two-way street. One of the biggest first date mistakes is dominating the conversation or revealing overly personal details too soon. While authenticity matters, unloading your life story in one sitting can feel overwhelming. Likewise, talking only about your achievements without asking questions can make you seem self-centred. The key is balance: listen actively, show interest, and share enough to spark curiosity.
Nothing kills the mood faster than being impolite to waiting staff or constantly checking your phone. These actions signal disinterest, impatience, or a lack of respect. Your date will notice—and may assume this is how you treat people in general. To avoid this, keep your phone out of sight and focus on creating a welcoming, respectful atmosphere.
From bragging about your job to exaggerating your hobbies, trying too hard to impress can come across as inauthentic. Your date wants to meet the real you, not a polished sales pitch. Overcompensating with rehearsed lines or forced humour can make the interaction feel unnatural. Relax, be yourself, and trust that genuine confidence is far more attractive than a scripted performance.
How to behave on a first date isn’t just about what you say—it’s also about how you respond. Ignoring signs of discomfort, boredom, or disinterest is a major mistake. Pay attention to body language, tone of voice, and facial expressions. Mutual respect and empathy create a safe, comfortable environment where connection can grow naturally.
Avoiding mistakes is only half the story—knowing what to do instead is what truly sets the stage for a memorable first meeting. These principles will help you create a relaxed, engaging atmosphere that encourages genuine connection and leaves room for the possibility of a second date.
Put away distractions, maintain eye contact, and show genuine curiosity about your date’s thoughts, interests, and experiences. Being present signals respect and creates space for authentic conversation.
While deep conversations have their place, a first date is often best suited for light, engaging topics that help you learn about each other without overwhelming the mood. Humour, shared interests, and positive stories work wonders.
If you’re hoping for a second meeting, leave your date intrigued rather than overloaded. A little mystery keeps anticipation alive. End on a positive note, and if you feel a connection, express genuine interest in seeing them again.
If the idea of meeting someone new fills you with nerves, you’re not alone. Many professionals struggle with first date tips in practice, even if they know them in theory. This is where services like Macbeth Matchmaking can help. From personalised dating coaching to compatibility screening and post-date feedback, a professional matchmaker can help you prepare, feel confident, and focus on genuine connection rather than performance anxiety.
What is the biggest first date mistake people make?
Putting too much pressure on the outcome. This can lead to tension, forced conversation, and missed opportunities for natural chemistry.
How do I stop overthinking before a first date?
Focus on enjoying the experience rather than predicting the outcome. Prepare a few light conversation starters and remind yourself it’s simply a meeting to get to know someone.
Should I talk about my ex on a first date?
In most cases, no. Conversations about ex-partners can make things awkward and shift focus away from the present. Keep the discussion on mutual interests and future goals.
Is it bad to plan too much in advance?
Overplanning can create unnecessary pressure. While it’s smart to have a location and activity in mind, allow room for spontaneity and organic conversation.